Air Conditioner vs. Heat Pump: Which is Ideal for Homeowners in Newark? (Part 2)

Enduring summer heat with broken air conditioner or heat pump

Most people, when faced with the decision of being cool and comfortable during the extreme heat of Ohio summers, could care less whether they have a heat pump or an air conditioner. Most of us only care that our family is cool and comfortable. When it’s time to replace your home’s cooling equipment, it’s nice to know what options are available, and what’s best for your home.

Many homeowners may be confused when they try to figure the differences between the two devices, air conditioner or heat pump? This article should give you some solid clues to make the choice.

In part 2, we’ll review air conditioner systems and then compare the two.

Read part 1 of this series here.

What is Central Air Conditioning?

Air conditioners work very similar in fashion to a heat pump, removing heat from inside the home and pushing it outside. The primary difference is that a central air conditioning unit does one thing very well, it cools your home.

How Does an Air Conditioner Perform Its Magic?

A central air conditioner is a split unit that contains the following components:

  • An outside unit, containing a condenser and compressor
  • Evaporator coil inside the home (also frequently called an “a-coil” because of its shape)
  • Refrigeration lines, tubing that connects the two units
  • Coolant / refrigerant that circulates throughout the indoor and outdoor units
  • Fans that distribute the air through the home’s ductwork
  • A control panel (thermostat) that allows the homeowner to manage the temperature

Air conditioners rely on the refrigerant in the system to perform the magic of absorbing heat from inside the home and releasing it outside. Air conditioners do exactly as their name suggests: dehumidify and condition the air inside the home. Any water vapor, AKA humidity, in the air makes it difficult for our bodies to regulate its temperature. When the mercury rises, our bodies feel overheated, but air conditioners remove humidity from the air and makes our skin surface feel cooler.

Advantages and Disadvantages of Air Conditioning

Large homes with existing ductwork are the perfect environment to install central air conditioning. In a Central AC system, cooling processes and fans circulate the air throughout the home using a system of ducts that keep your family cool and comfortable.

Benefits of Air Conditioning

In today’s modern world, we don’t have to spell out exactly what air conditioning does. But from a technical perspective, air conditioners are a specialized piece of equipment with a single task: remove warm, humid air from the inside and move it outside. And modern air conditioners perform that task very, very well. They can produce just the right amount of cooled air and circulate it through your home. Central air conditioning systems also improve indoor air quality by filtering the air and reducing allergens.

Disadvantages of Air Conditioning

One of the biggest “issues” with air conditioners is they cannot create heat, requiring another piece of equipment for that task. If the outside air temperature drops below about 55 degrees in the winter, heat is a necessity. That means an AC system must be matched with a furnace to provide winter temperature control, requiring a higher price tag.

Decide Between AC and Heat Pump

As we’ve examined in this series, there are a lot of similarities between heat pumps and central air conditioners. Both units use existing ductwork in a home, and both are powered by electricity. When in cooling mode, both air conditioners and heat pumps cool the home by extracting heat and humidity from the inside and moving it outside.

What are the deciding factors between a central air conditioning unit or a heat pump?

Factor Number 1: Purchase and Installation Cost

Each homeowner’s situation is going to be unique, but the major factor in deciding between the two types of systems is the cost to purchase and install the system. AC systems can vary in price between $4,900 and $13,000 in the Newark, Ohio area, with a heat pump cost about 10-15% more than that.

Factor Number 2: Operating Costs and Energy Efficiency

Air conditioning systems and heat pumps are rated by their Season energy Efficiency Ratio (SEER). SEER measures the cooling output of a cooling system during a typical cooling system. Heat pumps are also measured by their Heating Seasonal Performance Factor (HSPF). With either measurement, you can get high performance results.

If you are constantly changing temperatures in your home, or it has a lot of southern exposure windows, you’re doing to see lower efficiency, no matter the SEER rating. During the cooling season, air conditioners and heat pumps with similar SEER ratings and going to cost about the same to operate. During mild winters, however, a heat pump is going to be more efficient, with lower heating costs, than a gas fired furnace. If the temperature drops below 30 degrees on a regular basis, that energy savings advantage is lost.

Factor Number 3: Equipment Life Expectancy

Since heat pumps work year round (as mentioned in part 1), potentially reducing their life expectancy. On the other hand, and AC system only needs to work when the outside temperatures are warm. They get a break in the winter when the furnace is doing the heavy lifting. A heat pump’s shorter life span could be offset by lower operating costs during mild winters.

Heat pumps work really well at temperatures over freezing, only needing just enough energy to maintain warm temperatures in the home. Regular annual tune-ups for either type of system will extend the longevity and keep them running at maximum efficiency.

The Bottom Line

The bottom line is that heat pumps are more popular in more temperate sections of the country like the south. And the tried-and-true combination of air conditioner and furnace are usually the right choice for central Ohio. Heat pumps, however, are making gains as manufacturers are starting to improve their ability to heat at lower temperatures… but we’re just not quite there yet.

The answer to the question posed in the title is that traditional air conditioning and furnaces are just about right for the Ohio seasons, unless we see milder winters each year.

If you’re in the market for a new system, it’s worthwhile to have a professional evaluation of your current system and ask our estimator if he thinks heat pumps might be a good fit for your home.

Reading part one of this series

Dor-Mar to the Rescue!

Schedule an appointment for HVAC system installation, troubleshooting or maintenance with us today by using our online contact form, or call one of our seven neighborhood offices listed below. We pride ourselves on our customer-focused service, and our reviews show it.

NEWARK  740.345.6639 • COLUMBUS 614.238.6689 • DUBLIN 614.545.8939 • REYNOLDSBURG 614.365.1579 • WESTERVILLE 614.381.1540 • GROVE CITY 614.595.3098 • ZANESVILLE 740.454.2420

Dor-Mar…Your Climate Hero!


In continuous operation since 1962, our expertise goes beyond just the mechanicals of your HVAC system. We’re pretty handy when it comes to ductwork and system-wide maintenance as well. For top-notch service keeping your home’s heating and cooling system clean and your family breathing clean, filtered air, contact Dor-Mar today.

Our team offers a wide array of routine maintenance and emergency services for your heating and cooling system, allowing your family to breathe fresh, safe, clean air and be comfortable year-round. We also offer a number of add-ons to your HVAC equipment that can improve your home’s Indoor Air Quality (IAQ), such as electrostatic air filters, whole-house humidifiers, duct cleaning, Ultraviolet-C lighting systems, and more.

Schedule an appointment for HVAC system troubleshooting or maintenance with us today by using our online contact form, or call one of local offices listed below. We pride ourselves on our customer-focused service, and our reviews show it.

Dor-Mar…Your Climate Hero!

Steven Brewer<br/>HVAC Expert & Owner

Steven Brewer
HVAC Expert & Owner

I started in the HVAC business as a young man, with my father putting me in crawl spaces to run ductwork while on summer vacation from school; I began full time in our family HVAC business at the age of 19. I obtained my state commercial HVAC license at 25. I'm married with three kids, and I love boating, fishing and hunting.

All Posts

More Posts

Vote for Dor-Mar fo Community Choice Awards

VOTE for Dor-Mar

We are thrilled to announce that Dor-Mar Heating & Air Conditioning has been selected as one of the top five finalists for the 2023 Community Choice Awards in Licking County, in the Heating/AC Service Company category! Being nominated for this award is an honor in itself, but being chosen as a finalist truly reflects the

hvac furnace filter types

Choosing the Right Air Filter for Your Home: Factors to Consider

As homeowners, we all want to make sure that our homes are comfortable and safe for us and our loved ones. One important aspect of home maintenance is ensuring that the air we breathe is clean and healthy. A good air filter can help keep your home’s air quality at its best. However, with so

benefits of upgrading to a high-efficiency HVAC system

Benefits of Upgrading to a High-Efficiency HVAC System

Upgrading to a high-efficiency HVAC (Heating, Ventilation, and Air Conditioning) system offers numerous benefits for homeowners. Not only does it enhance comfort and indoor air quality, but it also leads to significant energy savings and a reduced environmental impact. If you’re considering an upgrade, here are some compelling reasons to make the switch: 1. Increased

gas fired furnace repair man in Newark OH

Understanding Different Heating System Types

When it comes to keeping your home warm and cozy during the colder months, it’s important to have an understanding of the different heating system types available. From traditional furnaces to newer, more energy-efficient options, each type of heating system has its own unique advantages and disadvantages. In this article, we’ll explore the most common


HVAC customer service in Newark, Ohio | Dor-Mar Heating & Air Conditioning

PLEASE NOTE: If you are a renter, please have your landlord/owner contact us directly to schedule service. We can only work with property owners.


Need a quick answer to a question? Enter your question below and we’ll get back to you with an answer. FAST!


HVAC customer service in Newark, Ohio | Dor-Mar Heating & Air Conditioning


Our Comittment to Your Family’s Health & Safety

Learn what we’re doing to keep you and your family, as well as our employees, safe from the spread of the virus as we service your heating and cooling needs.